Research
Why the rules of Ananda Marga exist
Expansion and contraction of the self: yama, niyama, the fifteen shiilas and the sixteen points as sequential work on the feeling of “I”
[Draft]
Abstract
This work answers one question: what do the rules of Ananda Marga do to the feeling of “I”. The answer is that they neither destroy the self nor inflate it; they change what the self identifies with. The shastras give the criterion: virtue expands the mind, vice contracts it. But expansion can be false — into things, status, and another’s pain — and then a rule cuts it. Yama contracts the false expansion of the self; niyama expands the self beyond the body and comfort; the fifteen shiilas expand it to the other person; the sixteen points stabilise the body and rhythm without which the shift cannot happen. The reading stays with the shastras; it does not import psychology or outside theories. Each rule is treated in one sequence: definition, mechanism, example, what changes in the feeling of “I”. The work does not assess practitioners and does not promise release from the rules; it shows the logic by which the rules work.
1. The question
The usual explanation of the rules says: they are needed to “reduce the ego.” The formula is convenient, but it explains nothing. It does not say what is reduced, where, or by what sign one can check whether it has been reduced. Any behaviour can be called ego, and any rule can be called work on ego. Such an explanation cannot be refuted, and for that reason it is not research.
The shastras put the question more precisely. There is an “I” that says “I am,” an “I” that says “I do” and “this is mine,” and an object with which the first identifies. The rules work not on “the self” in general but on this identification. They change not the quantity of the self but its place: from a thing to an action, from an action to a thought, from a thought to the witness.
The question of this work is therefore: what does a rule do to the object of identification, and in which direction does the feeling of “I” move? The answer cannot be the same for every rule. Yama, niyama, the shiilas and the sixteen points act at different levels and in a different order. They cannot be read as one list of prohibitions.
The thesis: the rules do not make the self smaller. They make it smaller where it has swollen into what is not its own, and larger where it has contracted to the body, fear, and comparison. The criterion is not the number of rules or the strength of self-denial, but the direction in which the self moves.
2. The structure of “I”
In Ānanda Sūtram, mind is described in three layers. The first is mahattattva, the sense of existence, “I am.” The second is ahaṃtattva, the sense of doer and owner, “I do,” “this is mine.” The third is citta, the objectivated mind that has taken the form of an object. The layers arise in order: first “I am,” then “I do,” then “this is mine.”
“As the result of the initial impact of Prakrti on the witnessing Puruṣottama, there awakens in Him the sense of existence, which in the language of philosophy is called the Mahattattva [Existential “I”] … The second impact of the operative force of Prakrti results in the emergence of the sense of doership or authorship. This changed expression of Puruṣa is called the Ahaṃtattva (Doer “I”) … Finally … comes the crudest objectivity or complete objectivation of Puruṣa … This condition of Puruṣa is called citta (mind-stuff).”
Above these three layers is the witness. It is neither object, nor doer, nor the sense of existence. Ānanda Sūtram says: if the expression of citta is called action, its apparent witness is ahaṃ; if the expression of ahaṃ is called action, its witness is mahat; if the expression of mahat is called action, its witness is “I know I am.” This witness is not produced by the mind and does not disappear with the object.
Hence the first clarification. “Ego” in ordinary speech mixes three different things: ahaṃ as the function of the doer, inflation as appropriation, and the “small self” as selfishness. In the shastras these are not one variable. Ahaṃ is necessary: without it one cannot act. Mahat is necessary: without it there is no sense of existence. The problem begins not with their existence but with ahaṃ identifying with citta and saying “I am this.”
The second clarification concerns “destroying the ego.” Ananda Marga Ideology says that the “I”-feeling cannot destroy itself: it is the ego that sets out to destroy the “I”-feeling, and therefore egoism is the subtlest expression of mind, not a separate enemy.5 The formula “kill the ego” is imprecise: there is nothing to kill while there is someone doing the killing. It is more exact to speak of changing the object: what does ahaṃ identify with?
An example that will recur. A person sees a cup. Citta takes the form of the cup. Ahaṃ says “I see the cup.” Mahat says “I am.” The witness says “I know that I am.” None of these layers is the cup. But if the person says “this is my cup,” ahaṃ has identified with the object. If the cup breaks, what suffers is not the cup and not the witness, but the identification. The rules work on this link.
Thus the question “does the self expand or contract” cannot be settled at the level of quantity. First one must determine what the self has identified with. Expansion into a cup is not the same as expansion into a person. Contraction to a cup is not the same as contraction to the body. Section 3 gives the criterion that distinguishes these cases.
3. What expansion and contraction mean
The criterion is stated directly. The Great Universe says: “virtue is that which helps to expand the mind, by whose assistance the universe increasingly becomes an integral part of oneself, and vice is that which makes the mind narrow and selfish.”2 Virtue is not the observance of a list; it is the expansion of mind in which the universe becomes part of oneself. Vice is contraction, in which the mind closes on itself.
But “expansion” here does not mean “more sensations” or “more possessions.” The mind by its nature takes the form of its object. If the object is money, the mind becomes money; if the object is fame, the mind becomes fame. Ānanda Vacanāmrtam 34 says plainly: “it is the characteristic of the human mind that it takes the form of its object.”6 Such expansion into an object is not liberation but coarsening.
Two expansions must therefore be distinguished. False expansion: the mind expands into a thing, a status, an opinion, a grievance. It feels like growth because the object is large, but the mind takes the form of the object and becomes just as limited. True expansion: the mind expands into the infinite, into what has no boundary. A Few Problems Solved 2 says that when the limited mind accepts the unlimited as its object, the mind expands to a full 360 degrees.7 Tantra defines liberation as expansion: “tan + trae” — to liberate through expansion; the mind is expanded to snap the bondages of vrttis, ripus, and pāśas.4
Contraction also has two kinds. False contraction: the mind contracts around comparison — “I am worse,” “I am better,” “he humiliated me.” Ānanda Vacanāmrtam 15 calls this kuṇṭhā: “Kuṇṭhā means contraction. Where mind is contracted, it is known as psychic contraction.” A poor man meets a rich man and the mind contracts; an uneducated man meets a scholar and the same happens.3 This is not expansion or contraction to Brahma, but a contraction around another’s gaze.
“Be Free from All Complexes” lists four forms of this contraction: superiority, inferiority, fear, and defeat. In each case the mind cannot flow freely because it compares itself with an imagined or real magnitude. This is not “ego” as strength but ego as wound: the stronger the contraction, the more the person is occupied with himself.
Hence the working definition. Expansion is the movement of the self toward a subtler and more general object, in which the boundary between self and other weakens. Contraction is the movement toward a cruder and more particular object, in which that boundary hardens. Yama cuts false expansion, niyama expands true identity, the shiilas extend the self to the other, and the sixteen points stabilise the base. The rest of the work follows the rules.
4. Yama: five cuts
Yama is the first half of the discipline. It is often translated as “prohibitions,” but more exactly it names five places where the self must not continue. Yama does not take life away from a person; it cuts the false expansion of the self into another’s pain, falsehood, another’s property, superfluous things, and a gross object of desire. Each rule below is treated in one sequence: definition, mechanism, example, what changes in the feeling of “I.”
4.1. Ahiṃsā: do not continue pain
Definition: “Not to inflict pain or hurt on anybody by thought, word or action, is Ahiṃsā.”8 Ahiṃsā begins not with the body but with thought: with the replay of an injury, with an imagined argument, with the wish that the other feel the same.
Mechanism: in a conflict the self expands into the role of victim and avenger. The mind replays the scene, looks for words that will hurt in return. Ahiṃsā cuts this continuation at the first link — in thought, then in word, then in action. It does not forbid feeling pain; it forbids turning pain into a project.
Example. Someone says something rude. The first reaction is hurt. The second is a mental dialogue in which I win. The third is the wish to answer in kind. Ahiṃsā stops the second and third steps. The first remains: the pain is there, but it has not become fuel for a new action.
What changes: the self stops being “the one who must answer.” The hurt remains a fact, but it stops being a task. This is the contraction of a false expansion: the self no longer occupies the place of judge and executioner.
4.2. Satya: do not create a second self
Definition: “The benevolent use of mind and words is Satya.”8 Satya is not “truth at any cost,” but the use of mind and words so that they help rather than destroy. Falsehood in this definition is not only an incorrect statement but a word that creates an extra entity.
Mechanism: when a person lies, he creates a second self — a version that must be remembered, defended, and reconciled with the first. This second self expands: every new lie requires another. Satya cuts this expansion at the moment of choosing a word. It does not require telling everything; it requires not creating a split.
Example. A person is late and says there was a traffic jam, though he simply misjudged the time. The first lie requires a second — about the route, about when he left. The mind is occupied not with the work but with maintaining the version. Satya says: “I misjudged the time.” One sentence instead of a construction.
What changes: the self stops being the author of a version and becomes the one who speaks about a fact. The need to remember who was told what disappears. This is contraction: less self to maintain.
4.3. Asteya: do not take what is another’s, even in desire
Definition: “To renounce the desire to acquire or retain the wealth of others is Asteya. Asteya means ‘non-stealing.’”8 The word “desire” matters: asteya begins not with the hand but with the wish to appropriate what is not one’s own.
Mechanism: the self expands into what belongs to another — another’s work, reputation, place. Even if the act is not performed, the mind is already building “mine” where there is none. Asteya cuts not only the act but this construction.
Example. In a joint project a person tells the result in a way that makes it seem he did more. Formally he has stolen nothing; in fact he has taken a share of recognition. Asteya stops the wish to appropriate another’s contribution before it becomes a sentence.
What changes: the self stops expanding into what is another’s. What is another’s remains another’s, and this is not a loss but release from the need to guard what does not belong to one.
4.4. Aparigraha: do not become things
Definition: “To renounce everything excepting the necessities for the maintenance of the body is known as Aparigraha.”8 Aparigraha does not demand poverty; it demands the distinction between necessity and excess.
Mechanism: the self expands into accumulation. Things become an extension of the body and a confirmation of existence: “I have, therefore I am.” The more things, the more places where the self can be lost. Aparigraha cuts this equation before it becomes dependence.
Example. A person collects books, tools, or clothes he never uses. The thing itself is not the problem; the problem is that he feels larger by owning it. Aparigraha asks: is this needed for the body and the work, or is it needed for the image of myself? If the second, the thing is excess.
What changes: the self stops being a collection. Things remain things, not parts of oneself. This is the contraction of a false expansion and, at the same time, an expansion: the freed place is no longer occupied by guarding clutter.
4.5. Brahmacarya: change the object, do not suppress the desire
Definition: “To keep the mind always absorbed in Brahma is Brahmacarya.”8 Brahmacarya is not simple suppression; it is redirection. The mind cannot be empty; if you take away its object, it will find another. The rule therefore gives it a higher object.
Mechanism: the mind takes the form of its object. If the object is gross pleasure, the mind becomes gross; if the object is Brahma, the mind moves toward the subtle. Brahmacarya does not fight desire directly; it changes what the desire is directed toward.
Example. A person scrolls through a feed, and the mind fills with other people’s images. The prohibition “do not look” does not last, because emptiness demands filling. Brahmacarya offers a replacement: repetition of the name, ideation, reading, service. The mind receives an object, and the old object loses its power.
What changes: the self stops being the one who wants the object and becomes the one who moves toward the goal. The desire is not destroyed; it has received another direction.
The result of yama: five rules cut five forms of false expansion. None of them says “you are bad.” They say: here your self continues where it is not. The cut returns the self to where it actually is.
5. Niyama: five expansions
Niyama is the second half. If yama cuts false expansion, niyama expands true identity. It is often read as “prescriptions,” but more exactly it names five objects and actions in which the self can grow without becoming coarser.
5.1. Śaoca: remove the gross to see the subtle
Definition: “Śaoca is of two kinds – purity of the body and of the mind. The methods for mental purity are kindliness towards all creatures, charity, working for the welfare of others and being dutiful.”8 Śaoca is not only washing; it is removing what has stuck to the mind.
Mechanism: dirt of the body and dirt of the mind both narrow attention. When the body is unclean, the mind is occupied with the body; when the mind is full of resentment, it is occupied with resentment. Śaoca returns attention to what is in front of one. Outer cleanliness is a condition; inner cleanliness is kindness, charity, service, duty.
Example. Before sādhanā a person washes. This is not a ritual for its own sake: the body stops being a source of irritation, and the mind can sit. The same principle applies in conflict: if the mind is cleaned by a kind action, resentment does not occupy the whole place.
What changes: the self stops being the one occupied with itself and its irritation. Space appears for the other.
5.2. Santoṣa: stop comparison
Definition: “Contentment with things received unasked-for is santoṣa. It is essential to try to be cheerful always.”8 Santoṣa is not passivity; it is the refusal to measure oneself by another’s measure.
Mechanism: comparison contracts the mind. The poor before the rich, the uneducated before the scholar, the weak before the strong — in each case the mind becomes smaller than it is. Santoṣa returns the self to what already is and stops the comparison.
Example. A person sees another’s success and feels that his own life is smaller. Santoṣa does not say that success does not matter; it says: your life is not measured by his success. The self stops being relative.
What changes: the self leaves the contraction of “worse/better.” It becomes simply I, not I-by-comparison.
5.3. Tapah: go beyond comfort
Definition: “To undergo physical hardship to attain the objective is known as Tapah.”8 Tapah is not self-punishment but a test of where the self ends and comfort begins.
Mechanism: comfort creates a boundary: “I am what is convenient for me.” Tapah expands the boundary by showing that the self is more than comfort. Fasting, service, study are different forms of one thing: voluntarily passing through discomfort for the goal.
Example. A student sits down to study although he wants to sleep. The first minutes are unpleasant; then the mind enters the subject. Tapah does not make study sacred; it shows that an unpleasant beginning is not the boundary of the self.
What changes: the self stops being the one who demands comfort. The capacity to act when it is inconvenient appears.
5.4. Svādhyāya: give the mind an object above itself
Definition: “The study, with proper understanding, of scriptures and philosophical books is svādhyāya.”8 Svādhyāya is not the accumulation of information but the assimilation of meaning that changes the mind.
Mechanism: the mind takes the form of its object. If the object is gossip, the mind becomes gossip; if the object is shastra, the mind receives a subtler form. Svādhyāya gives the mind an object larger than the current self.
Example. A person reads a page about kuṇṭhā and recognises his own contraction before a rich man. He does not merely remember the term; he sees the mechanism in himself. This is assimilation, not the collection of quotations.
What changes: the self receives a language for its own movement. Not “I am bad,” but “I contracted, and this is how it works.”
5.5. Īśvara Praṇidhāna: become an instrument
Definition: “This is to have firm faith in Īśvara (the Cosmic Controller) in pleasure and pain, prosperity and adversity, and to think of oneself as the instrument, and not the wielder of the instrument, in all the affairs of life.”8 This is the strongest expansion: the self stops being the owner of the action.
Mechanism: while I am the doer, every action creates anxiety: did it succeed, was it recognised. When I am an instrument, the result is not mine. The mind is released from defending authorship.
Example. A person does a piece of work and waits for praise. There is no praise — and the self contracts. Īśvara Praṇidhāna says: the work was an instrument, not you. Praise does not add self; its absence does not take self away.
What changes: the self stops being the owner of the result. This is not passivity; the action remains, but its centre shifts.
The result of niyama: five rules give the self subtler objects. They do not add prohibitions; they add places where the self can grow without becoming coarser.
6. The fifteen shiilas: I and the other
The fifteen shiilas are not a second code beside yama and niyama. The tenth item is yama and niyama themselves, so the shiilas are their social form. If yama and niyama work with the inner movement of the self, the shiilas show how that movement looks in relation to another person.
The list: forgiveness; magnanimity of mind; perpetual restraint on behaviour and temper; readiness to sacrifice everything of individual life for ideology; all-round self-restraint; sweet and smiling behaviour; moral courage; setting an example by individual conduct; keeping aloof from criticism, condemnation, mudslinging and groupism; strict adherence to yama and niyama; immediate admission of a mistake and asking for punishment; freedom from hatred, anger and vanity even with a hostile person; keeping aloof from talkativeness; obedience to the structural code of discipline; sense of responsibility.9
They fall into four movements. First, stop the contraction around the other: forgiveness, restraint, refusal of criticism and groupism, freedom from hatred, refusal of talkativeness. Second, expand the circle: magnanimity, readiness for sacrifice, sweet behaviour, moral courage, personal example, responsibility. Third, make the self transparent: admission of mistakes, self-restraint, adherence to yama and niyama. Fourth, keep the form: discipline and obedience to the structural code.
Return to the example of rudeness. Forgiveness stops the mental replay: I do not continue the scene. Magnanimity widens the view: the other also has a state, and his rudeness is not his whole being. Refusal of criticism and groupism prevents turning the incident into a camp of “us against him.” Freedom from hatred allows firm action without the wish to destroy. Admission of a mistake is needed if I have already answered with rudeness. Responsibility requires not only not to take revenge but to restore the work.
What changes: the self stops being the centre of the conflict. It does not become “good” in the sense of soft; it becomes wider than the injury. The shiilas expand the self to the other not because the other is good, but because the boundary “I/he” stops being absolute.
Here it is important not to turn the shiilas into moral sport. Forgiveness does not mean agreement with harm; restraint does not mean silence; refusal of criticism does not mean refusal of discrimination. Each item works only together with yama and niyama: without ahiṃsā forgiveness becomes suppression, without satya magnanimity becomes a lie, without tapah restraint becomes a mask.
7. The sixteen points: body and rhythm
The sixteen points are often read as a hygiene list. In the context of work on the self they do something else: they stabilise the body and the rhythm without which the self can neither cut nor expand. If the body is unclean, the mind is occupied with the body; if the day has no rhythm, the mind is occupied with time; if there is no sādhanā, the mind is occupied with itself. The points remove these obstacles.10
1–6. The body. Washing, cleaning, care of the body, śaoca, bathing. The point is not to make the body “spiritual” but to make it stop being a source of constant irritation. Example: before sādhanā a person washes; afterwards he does not need to be distracted by itch, smell, or fatigue. The body becomes a seat, not a topic.
7–8. Food and fasting. Sāttvika food and fasting. The mind depends on the body, and the body on food. Heavy food makes the mind heavy; fasting shows that the self is not identical with hunger. Example: a person notices that after a heavy meal he cannot sit quietly. He does not declare food an enemy; he sees the connection and chooses what does not obstruct.
9. Sādhanā. Regular practice. This is the only point that works directly on expansion; the others prepare it. Without sādhanā the rules become moral gymnastics; with sādhanā they become support.
10–14. Faith and identity. Iṣṭa, ādarśa, the Supreme Command, the conduct rules, the oaths. Here the self receives an object above itself. Example: at a moment of temptation a person remembers not “I must be good” but “I am going toward this goal.” The oath returns the centre.
15–16. Community. The weekly dharmacakra and CSDK — conduct rules, seminar, duty, kīrtana. The self leaves its private rhythm for a collective one. Example: a person sings with others and for a time stops being the centre of attention. This is not the dissolution of personality but the experience of a wider self.
The sixteen points are not a “lower” part of the discipline. They are the foundation. If the foundation does not hold, yama and niyama become a struggle with the body, and the shiilas become tension. The rules work not because the person is strong, but because the body and the day are arranged so that strength is not spent on obstacles.
8. How the rules work together
The order of the rules is logical, not chronological. First the body and rhythm — the sixteen points. Then conduct with the other — the fifteen shiilas. Then the inner cuts — yama. Then the inner expansions — niyama. Then sādhanā, which joins everything. Each level supports the next, but does not replace it.
If one begins with yama without body and rhythm, the cut becomes violence against oneself: a person forbids himself food, sleep, reaction, but receives no new object. If one begins with niyama without yama, expansion becomes collecting: more books, more practices, more experience, but the old self remains the centre. If one begins with the shiilas without yama and niyama, behaviour becomes a mask: the person smiles, but inside he continues to contract.
Ananda Marga Ideology 6 gives the precise map of the movement: “Merge the propensities expressed by your indriyas into citta, citta into ahaṃtattva, ahaṃtattva into mahattattva, mahattattva into jiivātmā and jiivātmā into Paramātmā.”11 This is not a description of a physical process but a map: tendencies → objects → doer → sense of existence → witness → Brahma. The rules work at different points on this map.
The sixteen points work with the indriyas and the body: they do not let tendencies become the only content of the day. The fifteen shiilas work with the relation to the other: they do not let the self contract to “me against him.” Yama works with ahaṃ: it cuts identification with what is another’s and superfluous. Niyama works with mahat: it gives the sense of existence a subtler object. Sādhanā works with the witness: it returns the self to what is neither object nor doer.
Hence the answer to the original question. The rules do not “destroy the ego” and do not “expand the self” in general. They move the centre of gravity: from “mine” to “I do,” from “I do” to “I am,” from “I am” to “I know that I am.” In each transition something is cut and something is expanded. Yama cuts false expansion; niyama expands true identity; the shiilas extend to the other; the sixteen points hold body and rhythm; sādhanā completes the movement.
The criterion remains one: does the mind expand so that the universe becomes part of it, or contract so that it becomes part of a thing. Everything else is technique.
9. Limits
This work is not psychology. It does not measure the ego, build scales, or cite outside research. Its material is the shastras; its method is the analysis of definitions and logical links. Where the shastras speak directly, there is a quotation; where the conclusion is ours, this is stated.
The shastras are normative: they prescribe, they do not describe how people actually behave. The work therefore does not claim that followers of the tradition always act according to the rules. It describes the logic of the rules, not the practice of a movement.
The rules do not replace sādhanā and do not replace grace. Ananda Marga Ideology 6 says: “moralism is not the goal – it is the starting point.”11 The rules prepare the mind; they are not the goal. A person may observe them and remain inside the same contraction if the object of identification does not change.
Expansion is not the same as a pleasant feeling. Tapah may be unpleasant; ahiṃsā may require giving up a habitual reaction; satya may be inconvenient. If a person expects the right action always to feel pleasant, he will confuse expansion with comfort.
Finally, the work does not assess anyone’s spiritual level and does not issue political or social prescriptions. Sadvipra, PROUT, and outside theories do not belong here: that is another topic. Here there is only one question — what the rules do to the feeling of “I.”
10. Conclusion
The rules of Ananda Marga are not a list of prohibitions and not a way to “reduce the ego.” They are a technique for moving the self. Yama cuts the false expansion of the self into another’s pain, falsehood, another’s property, superfluous things, and a gross object. Niyama gives the self subtler objects: purity, contentment, effort, knowledge, instrumentality. The fifteen shiilas expand the self to the other. The sixteen points hold the body and rhythm without which this shift is impossible.
The essence of the rules can be put in one sentence: they make the self smaller where it has swollen into what is not its own, and larger where it has contracted to the body, fear, and comparison. This is not morality for morality’s sake and not self-annihilation. It is work on what a person identifies with, until only that remains which is neither object nor doer.
Sources
Links open the reader at the relevant chapter. Collections require sign-in. Quotations are kept in the original; the English text is analysis, not a substitute for the source.
- Ānanda Sūtram. 1-5; 1-7; 2-9. reader
- The Great Universe. “The Need for a Spiritual Ideal.” reader
- Ānanda Vacanāmrtam. Part 15. “Nāham Tiṣṭhāmi Vaekuṇṭhe.” reader
- Ananda Marga Philosophy in a Nutshell. Part 6. “Tantra.” reader
- Ananda Marga Ideology and Way of Life in a Nutshell. Part 2. “The Supreme Entity.” reader
- Ānanda Vacanāmrtam. Part 34. “Be Free from All Complexes.” reader
- A Few Problems Solved. Part 2. “The Cosmic Ideology.” reader
- Ānanda Mārga Caryācārya. Part 2. “Sādhanā”; Yama and Niyama. reader
- Ānanda Mārga Caryācārya. Part 2. “Paiṋcadasha Shiila (The Fifteen Rules of Behaviour).” reader
- Ānanda Mārga Caryācarya. Part 2. “Sixteen Points.” reader
- Ananda Marga Ideology and Way of Life in a Nutshell. Part 6. “The Primordial Cause of Creation.” reader
18 November 2026